Collective Bargaining
Stronger Representation. Smarter Negotiations.
Advanced Corporations specializes in collective bargaining and strategic negotiations for public safety associations. We combine decades of institutional knowledge, extensive bargaining experience, industry-leading compensation research, and comprehensive financial analysis to maximize your bargaining power and secure stronger contracts.
Choose a serviceChoose a service. Swipe to see all five.
Memberships · How do we get it done?
Three membership choices
Choose by who leads at the table and how much of the work you want us to carry. All three rest on the same foundation: our institutional knowledge and our compensation, financial and costing research.
Collective Bargaining
We represent you at the table.
Advanced Corporations represents the Association during negotiations and meets with the employer, in person or by teleconference, as needed.
You want an experienced negotiator to lead for the Association.
Negotiation Consulting
We advise and prepare while your team leads.
Advanced Corporations provides the analysis, advice and preparation. Your own team leads the employer meetings and presents its positions.
Your team will lead, and you want the same studies and preparation behind it.
Service Membership
Selected studies and defined member benefits.
Two study cycles of the studies in your tier, plus member benefits. Choose from three tiers, compared below. It does not include full proposal and counterproposal development, full negotiation consulting or bargaining representation.
You want current studies and an experienced outside perspective.
What is included
What each membership includes
Service Membership tiersTier 1 Compensation StudyTier 2 Financial AnalysisTier 3 Both studies and Contract Costing
| Benefit | Collective Bargaining | Negotiation Consulting | Service Membership | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tier 1Compensation Study | Tier 2Financial Analysis | Tier 3Both studies and Contract Costing | |||
| Representation at the bargaining tableIn person or by teleconference, as needed. | Included | Not included | Not included | Not included | Not included |
| Financial Analysis, in two study cyclesThe employer’s ability to pay and competing fiscal priorities. | Included | Included | Not included | Included | Included |
| Compensation Study, in two study cycles | Included | Included | Included | Not included | Included |
| Interactive Comp Study Dashboard (proprietary technology) | Included | Included | Included | Not included | Included |
| Contract Costing, including the cost of proposed wage changes | Included | Included | Not included | Not included | Included |
| Compaction Study (pay compression) | Included | Included | Included | Not included | Included |
| Comparable Agency Finder (proprietary technology) | Included | Included | Included | Not included | Included |
| Review of the employer’s compensation studyFor errors, omissions, unsupported assumptions, and methodological issues. | Included | Included | Included | Not included | Included |
| Fact presentation of all study findings to the employerCollective Bargaining: we present them. Negotiation Consulting: we prepare them and your team delivers. Tier 3: when needed. | Included | Included | Included | Included | Included |
| Member survey for negotiation preparationTo identify priorities, needs, and concerns. | Included | Included | Included | Included | Included |
| Proposal and counterproposal developmentNegotiation Consulting: developed with your team. | Included | Included | Not included | Not included | Not included |
| Union leadership support and strategic guidance | Included | Included | Included | Included | Included |
| Continuity of service throughout the membership | Included | Included | Included | Included | Included |
| Monthly payments at 0% interest and no hourly billing for included work | Included | Included | Included | Included | Included |
| Guaranteed pricing | Included | Included | Included | Included | Included |
Included Not included
Collective Bargaining and Negotiation Consulting also include board and membership presentations, political guidance and expert consulting.
Every membership includes two scheduled study cycles, planned around your MOU timeline. Service Membership includes the listed products and member benefits, including a limited second opinion or quick proposal review. It does not include full negotiation consulting, full proposal or counterproposal development, or bargaining representation.
Service Membership
Member benefits
- Leadership SupportAn experienced outside perspective for Association presidents and boards who also work full-time.
- AccessibilityA second opinion or quick review of a proposal without ordering a separate formal report.
- Long-Term PlanningHelp setting compensation goals and identifying financial issues before the next negotiation.
In detail
The full list for each membership
Collective Bargaining
This membership includes direct representation during negotiations. Advanced Corporations meets with the employer during negotiations, in person or by teleconference, as needed. Our institutional knowledge of employer bargaining behavior and public agency budgeting shapes every strategy.
- Two scheduled cycles of Compensation and Financial Studies
- Review of the employer’s compensation study for errors, omissions, unsupported assumptions, and methodological issues
- Financial Analysis of the employer’s ability to pay and competing fiscal priorities
- Contract Costing, including the one-percent cost of proposed wage changes
- Interactive Comp Study Dashboard (proprietary technology)
- Compaction Study (pay compression)
- Comparable Agency Finder (proprietary technology)
- Development of proposals and counterproposals
- Presentations of study findings and supporting facts to the employer
- Member surveys to identify priorities, needs, and concerns
- Union leadership support and strategic guidance
- Preparation of presentations for the Association’s board and membership
- Political guidance related to negotiations
- Expert consulting on pensions, Association leadership, and union management
- Continuity of service throughout the membership
- Communications support for board members, presidents, and members
- Proposal and counterproposal drafting support, including automation that assists preparation. Automated drafts are not final or ready to use without review
- Ongoing Financial Tracking of the employer’s finances
Negotiation Consulting
This membership includes the same core studies and negotiation preparation, but the Association’s own team leads employer meetings and presents its positions. Advanced Corporations advises and prepares. It is not representation at the table. Your leadership stays directly responsible for the negotiation, with the benefit of our experience and institutional knowledge.
- Meetings with the Association’s negotiation team by phone or video. In-person team meetings may be arranged but are not required
- Two scheduled cycles of Compensation and Financial Studies
- Review of the employer’s compensation study for errors, omissions, unsupported assumptions, and methodological issues
- Financial Analysis of the employer’s ability to pay and competing fiscal priorities
- Contract Costing, including the one-percent cost of proposed wage changes
- Interactive Comp Study Dashboard (proprietary technology)
- Compaction Study (pay compression)
- Comparable Agency Finder (proprietary technology)
- Development of proposals and counterproposals with the Association’s team
- Preparation of employer fact presentations for the Association’s team to deliver
- Member surveys to identify priorities, needs, and concerns
- Union leadership support and strategic guidance
- Preparation of board and membership presentations
- Political guidance related to negotiations
- Expert consulting on pensions, Association leadership, and union management
- Continuity of service throughout the membership
- Communications support for board members, presidents, and members
- Proposal and counterproposal drafting support, including automation that assists preparation. Automated drafts are not final or ready to use without review
- Ongoing Financial Tracking of the employer’s finances
Service Membership
This option provides selected Compensation and Financial Studies and defined member benefits. It does not include full negotiation consulting or representation at the bargaining table.
Three tiers
- Tier 1: Compensation Study, Interactive Comp Study Dashboard, Compaction Study, Comparable Agency Finder, review of the employer’s compensation study, fact presentations, and member survey
- Tier 2: Financial Analysis, fact presentations, and member survey
- Tier 3: Compensation Study, Financial Analysis, Contract Costing, Interactive Comp Study Dashboard, Compaction Study, Comparable Agency Finder, review of the employer’s compensation study, fact presentations when needed, and member survey
Service Membership includes the listed products and member benefits, including a limited second opinion or quick proposal review. It does not include full negotiation consulting, full proposal or counterproposal development, or bargaining representation.
Each membership is paid as one predictable monthly fee for the membership you select and its included scope. Payments are equal and interest-free, with no down payment or financing fees, and work included in your membership is not billed by the hour. Separate charges may apply only to listed work or expenses outside the membership, under the contract terms and any required written approval.
Outside the memberships
Independent Research
One-time analytical product purchases. Purchase a total compensation study, an employer financial analysis or contract costing individually, or in a combination built for your association. No membership commitment is required.
No settlement is reached without your association’s explicit approval. We are not a law firm and do not provide legal representation.
Analytical research · Where do we stand?
Total compensation studies
Most salary surveys fail to look at all forms of compensation. Ours counts everything your members are paid, for every year of a career, measured against the agencies you compete with.
At a glance
- You receive
- A total compensation comparison for each classification you choose, from year 1 through year 30.
- Built on
- Your MOUs, salary schedules and the comparable agencies you choose with us.
- Depth
- A typical 12-agency study starts from more than 10,000 data points and runs more than 52,000 calculations.
- Available
- In Collective Bargaining, Negotiation Consulting and Service Membership Tiers 1 and 3, delivered according to your client agreement. Also available as Independent Research, a one-time purchase on its own or in a combination with our other research.
- Every form of compensationSalary, longevity, education and certificate pay, assignment pay, pension, healthcare, leave and more. A survey that stops at base pay misses most of the picture.
- Every year of a careerYear 1 through year 30, for each classification you choose. Because we test every year of a typical career, we can show you exactly where your association has a problem.
- You control the studyAdd raises, forecast or assume future raises, include assignment pay, leave an agency out, change the market measure and more. Change a setting and every page updates at once.
- Your choice of market measureAverage, median, a percentile or the top of the market.
- Built on the factfinding criteriaThe same comparability standards a factfinding panel weighs under California law.
−3.1%
Total compensation at 5 years of service is below the market average, 8th of 12 agencies
+3.4%
Total compensation at entry level is above the market average, 5th of 12 agencies
Sample study: police officer, compared with the market average
| Career stage | Total compensation | Rank (of 12) | Net earnings | Rank (of 12) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Entry level | +3.4% above | 5th | +0.9% above | 6th |
| 5 years | −3.1% below | 8th | −8.2% below | 10th |
| 10 years | −0.3% below | 7th | −5.3% below | 9th |
| 15 years | +4.0% above | 6th | +1.7% above | 8th |
| 20 years | +3.3% above | 5th | +1.8% above | 8th |
| 25 years | +3.0% above | 5th | +1.4% above | 8th |
| Maximum | +3.0% above | 5th | +1.4% above | 8th |
How to read this table. Each percentage compares the sample association with the market average of its 11 comparable agencies, as a share of the sample association’s own pay. Rank 1st is the highest paid of the 12 agencies.
Total compensation is pay plus the value of benefits. Net earnings is base and incentive pay minus the employee pension contribution.
Sample study. All names are fictional.
Inside the study
One page per year of service, nothing hidden
10,000+
Data points entered for a typical 12-agency study
52,000+
Calculations working on that study
5,760
Figures on the year-by-year pages alone: 30 years, 12 agencies and 16 pay and benefit items

Every agency, ranked
Your association and every comparable, side by side.
Every element of pay
Base salary, longevity, education and certificate pay, uniform, premium pay, pension, healthcare, holiday, vacation and sick leave.
Net earnings
After the employee’s pension contribution.
Gap to the market
Against the market average and median, on every page.
Guided tour with sample data, about a minute and a half. No sound. Captions are in the video.
Interactive dashboard
Your study as an interactive dashboard
Studies can also be delivered as a private dashboard for your board and your negotiators. The Controls tab is where it comes alive. The dashboard reruns the study’s calculations in your browser every time you change a setting, so changing the market measure or leaving an agency out updates every page at once. We check its year-by-year figures against the study every time, and they match.
What you can do in the dashboard
- Controls tab: choose the classification and market measure, add raises, forecast or assume future raises, include assignment pay, leave an agency out
- Watch every tab update as you change a setting
- Compare your agency with the market, year by year
- Hover for the numbers and open any year
- See all 30 years at a glance, or one year at a time
- Print the report or create a presentation
- Open calculators in the Tools tab (beta)
Comparable Agency Finder
Comparables you can defend
Choosing comparable agencies is often the first argument at the table. Our Comparable Agency Finder holds 12,114 agencies in all 50 states and DC, 8,494 law enforcement agencies and 3,620 fire departments, and ranks every candidate with a match score you can explain, built from staffing, population, household income, land area and other data, weighted the way your board chooses. Narrow the market by state, county or distance, see the candidates on a map, and export the ranked list as a Word exhibit, PDF or spreadsheet.
12,114
Agencies in all 50 states and DC
What you can do with it
- Search police or fire agencies nationwide
- Start with your agency’s profile
- Narrow the market by state, county or distance, and see it on a map
- Choose how many comparable agencies to show
- Rank candidates with a match score you can explain
- Remove any agency your board does not accept
- Export a Word exhibit, PDF, link, presentation, spreadsheet or Google Earth file
Guided tour of an example search, about one minute. No sound. Captions are in the video.
Analytical research · Can the employer pay?
Ability to pay. Priority to pay.
Two questions decide most negotiations. Can the employer afford a raise? And is public safety a priority when it decides what to fund? We read ten years of the employer’s own audited records and test what management says against what actually happened. Trust, but verify.
At a glance
- You receive
- A written analysis of the employer’s revenue, expenditures, reserves, cash and debt, with every adopted budget compared against the audited result.
- Built on
- Ten years of the employer’s own audited financial reports and adopted budgets.
- Available
- In Collective Bargaining, Negotiation Consulting and Service Membership Tiers 2 and 3. Also available as Independent Research, a one-time purchase on its own or in a combination with our other research. In Collective Bargaining and Negotiation Consulting, Ongoing Financial Tracking keeps the employer’s data current between comprehensive analyses.



Sample financial analysis, 26 pages. City name changed.
Trust, but verify · sample engagement
The city budgeted a General Fund deficit every year for ten years, −$208.7M combined. The audited results showed +$104.9M, a surplus in eight of the ten years.
Sample financial analysis from an actual engagement, city name changed.
The two questions every analysis answers
Question 1
Ability to pay
Can the employer afford a raise?
Revenue, expenditures, reserves, cash and debt from the audited financial reports, not the budget presentation.
Question 2
Priority to pay
Are you a priority?
What the employer chose to fund instead. Is public safety a priority, or is the money going somewhere else?
What we typically find
Trust, but verify
Employers under-project revenue and over-project expenditures, year after year. We compare every adopted budget with the audited result and show the pattern. When the same miss repeats for ten years, it stops looking like an accident, and council members, board members and residents deserve to see it.
Spending that outpaces revenue
When expenditures are outrunning revenue, we typically find more of the money going to non-priority spending, not public safety.
Reserves that keep growing
We document reserves and other discretionary funds growing year over year while the employer says it cannot afford a raise.
1%
The value of one percent
The full cost of a one percent wage increase across your bargaining unit
Analytical research · What does it really cost?
Contract costing
Contract costing is about getting it right. We calculate what a raise really costs for your entire unit, so every proposal on the table carries a price you can trust.
At a glance
- You receive
- A costing analysis of what a one percent raise costs for your whole unit.
- Built on
- Your total compensation study.
- Use it to
- Price your proposals and the employer’s counters on the same footing.
- Available
- In Collective Bargaining, Negotiation Consulting and Service Membership Tier 3. Also available as Independent Research, a one-time purchase on its own or in a combination with our other research.
Why it matters · hypothetical example
The employer says
$100,000
is what a 5% raise costs
Costed correctly
$50,000
is what that 5% raise really costs
The same money buys
10%
a raise twice as large
Where employer costing commonly goes wrong
Every vacancy filled
Charging at maximum exposure, with no allowance for the normal vacancy rate.
Everyone at the top step
Pricing every member at the top step, with every premium pay.
Charged twice
Including unfunded pension liability and overtime, even though overtime is partly a consequence of vacancies, so the unit is effectively charged twice.
Fixed costs in the raise
Including pension bonds and other fixed costs in the price of the raise.
What we do about it
Know your number
The true cost of one percent, built from your members’ actual pay and benefits.
Price every proposal
Cost your proposals and the employer’s counters on the same footing.
Challenge inflated estimates
When the employer overstates what your proposal costs, you have the math to show it.
Contract costing is built on a total compensation study.
Ongoing client support · Who stands with us?
Institutional knowledge that stands with you
Our institutional knowledge is a firmwide advantage, built by our team over decades of public safety leadership, labor relations and bargaining across California. It stands behind every study, strategy and negotiation, and every client benefits from it, from the first day.
With Collective Bargaining or Negotiation Consulting, we also develop a deep knowledge of your own contract, employer and goals.
At a glance
- Comprehensive studies
- Comprehensive total compensation studies and employer financial analyses, delivered according to your client agreement.
- Ongoing services
- Professional support throughout your membership, not only when a comprehensive report is delivered. The services included depend on the membership you select.
- Between studies
- Analytical support between comprehensive studies, as your bargaining needs develop.
Institutional knowledge
We understand how public employers bargain, budget and compensate, which strategies succeed at the table, and how agreements compare across police, fire, sheriff and other public safety agencies.
Strategic consultation
An experienced outside view for presidents and boards on leadership, pension and side letter questions. Relationships with management and elected officials, including political activity, are part of our consulting.
Ongoing Financial Tracking
We maintain and update relevant employer financial data to support informed bargaining decisions, track financial trends and strengthen future negotiations.
Proposal evaluation
We review proposals from either side and help you understand what each one means before you respond.
Member bargaining surveys
Surveys of your members that help your board understand their bargaining priorities.
Board and employer presentations
We present our findings to your board and, when appropriate, to the employer.
See what you will receive.
The sample compensation study and financial analysis show exactly what lands in your board’s hands.
